May 17, 2013

Dunedin Voice launching

by Pete George

About two years ago I started floating ideas for encouraging more public involvement and discussion in Dunedin issues,  and in local politics and national politics relevant to Dunedin.

I knew it would need ok put and drive from others so I have  been keeping for lookout for opportunities and interest.

Due to another initiative I’ve found some others with similar ideas, including encouraging debate, providing information and being a DCC watchdog.

The overall aim is to encouarge and provide an effective voice for people of Dunedin.   Hence the name Dunedin Voice.

Diane Yeldon has set up a Dunedin Voice. I will contribute to this, and in fact it will be available to anyone wanting to speak about issues that are important to Dunedin.

Diane is particularly interested in monitoring what happens in the workings of the council and within DCC – and contact with the DCC indicates that they are also interested in cooperating with providing better access to council information and encouraging discussion of council business.

This has just been started and will grow as it gets used.

Keep an eye on developments – Dunedin Voice.

This will be as good as we all make it work. If you are interested in becoming involved beyond reading and perhaps commenting contact Diane (details at Dunedin Voice) or me on petedgeorge@gmail.com

 

May 16, 2013

What’s up here?

by Pete George

Your Dunedin was set up to try some things. Over the last few months I have just kept ticking things over, I have been busy working on other things, including a couple of projects in Dunedin.

I’ll be having a bit of break from my usual blogging over the next week or so. I have other commitments. I may get a chance to do a bit if I can fit it in.

I’m sure the Internet will manage without me for a while.

When I come back something new will be announced.

May 16, 2013

Green candidate to contest Dunedin mayoralty?

by Pete George

I’ve heard from a number of sources that the Green Party is going to stand (or endorse) a candidate for the Dunedin mayoralty in this year’s local body elections. The 25th of May has been mentioned.

And at a public event this week a name was openly mentioned – Aaron Hawkins. This isn’t a big surprise, Hawkins stood for mayor and council in 2010 – see Mayoral Profile: Aaron Hawkins.

On Tuesday Hawkins posted an openly political attack on current mayor Dave Cull at The Daily Blog - Dunedin’s Mayor Our Very Own Karma Chameleon.

It’s interesting that Greens are becoming more openly active in local body politics. In the past political parties have not been a popular feature in local body elections so this is a risk for Greens.

In Dunedin financial management, council debt and escalating rates are are big issues. Greens are making a major play on financial policies in national politics, and are struggling to be seen as credible. Voters were happy to tolerate some controversial Green environmental policies, but there is more wariness about what has been seen as a fringe party suggesting extreme economic policies.

If Hawkins stands as a Green candidate that obviously positions him politically. Normanomics may be something any Green candidate may have trouble defending beyond the Green faithful.

His last election profile says:

How would you describe your politics?

Environmentally responsible and, if anything on a spectrum, probably centre-left.

Who have you voted for nationally?

I voted for [Dunedin North MP] Pete Hodgson, I think, in the last three elections and for the Green Party.

Probably not centre-left. Maybe he has become more Green in the last two and a half years.

Hawkins doesn’t seem to be very active on Facebook.

He is more active on Twitter, where he has obvious Green connections and is noticeably anti National. His twitter profile:

@MrAaronHawkins

Music & Opinions for @RadioOne91FM, Words for @RipItUpNZ,@TheDailyBlogNZ@InsidersDunedin, D Scene, [Your Publication Here]

If he does stand for mayor as a Green candidate we’ll hear a lot more about him and from him. It will certainly guarantee a hard fought and interesting mayoral campaign. It’s good for democracy to have a range of candidates.

His Daily Blog profile:

About Aaron Hawkins

Aaron HawkinsAaron Hawkins has been the producer and presenter of the breakfast radio programme on Radio One 91FM Dunedin since 2006, and for the past three years also served as its Music Director.

His student media credentials extend to print, where he spent five years writing for /Critic Te Arohi/, winning Best Review Writer on non-consecutive occasions (for Theatre & Music respectively) and Best Features Writer at the Aotearoa Student Press Awards.

His music writing has appeared in Rip It Up, Real Groove and No magazines, he has written performance reviews for the Otago Daily Times, he currently blogs on local cultural fare for Insiders Dunedin, and writes a regular column on local government issues for D Scene.

In recent years he has been invited into the shadowy world of punditry, appearing as a panellist on the University of Otago Centre for Theology & Public Issues series Public Square, and at the Dunedin leg of the Save TVNZ7 Roadshow. He is also a staunch advocate and lobbyist for the creative community, and sits on the board of both the Blue Oyster Arts Trust and the Dunedin Fringe Arts Trust.

At just 28, he already has about 20 years of political wonkishness behind him, since he started bringing Tom Scott cartoons to show-and-tell in primary school. In 2010 he stood for Mayor of Dunedin. He did not win.

Hawkins will have to improve substantially on his 2010 result (he’s likely to do that).

Candidate Affiliation First Preference
Votes  %
Dave Cull Greater Dunedin 21,757 48.60
Peter Chin Independent 14,084 31.46
Lee Vandervis 5,917 13.22
Aaron Hawkins Independent 1,527 3.41
Olivier Lequeux 1,164 2.60
Kevin Dwyer 197 0.44
Jimmy Knowles 124 0.28
Informal votes 57
Turnout 45,218 52.34

He was closer in the councillor vote – see Dunedin local elections, 2010

Greens are well supported in Dunedin in National elections, and there is a significant Green activist base in the city. If co-leader Metiria Turei helps in the campaign that will ensure more attention.

It’s risky for Greens to delve into political territory that other parties have kept a distance from.

But it will certainly add interest to the local body elections in Dunedin.

May 16, 2013

Aaron Hawkins challenges Dave Cull

by Pete George

An occasional author at The Daily Blog, Aaron Hawkins has challenged mayor Dave Cull on how Cull dealt with his involvement in the planned Dalai Lama visit – see Dunedin’s Mayor Our Very Own Karma Chameleon.

He took a very political angle:

I know what you’re thinking, China flexed it’s censorial muscle and the Mayor of Dunedin, joining our country’s Prime Minister John Key, decided to snub the Dalai Lama for fear of being shut out of the Chinese market.

No, I wasn’t thinking that at all.

National and locally, an awful lot of economic eggs seem to have been placed in that basket.

Yes, that’s because there are huge business opportunities in and with China. But we also have other significant trading partners, including Australia.

I still would have called him out on it, as would many others, but there is at least some integrity in saying: “Yep, I’m going to turn my back on our proud traditions of free speech and freedom of religion, to try and make Dunedin some money”.

In his bid for re-election, it would certainly be a vote winner in business / socially conservative circles. Instead he comes across as a limp centrist, bobbing along on conflicting currents of personal and political interests and not being altogether convincing at either.

Ah, the election, we have an election coming up.

Hawkins concludes:

Sadly, the ODT have since chosen to drop the story, but further concerns surround Cull’s claim that the decision to turn down the Dalai Lama invitation appeared to be made by his staff while he was in China. This presents us with three possibilities:

  1. Cull mislead reporters, and residents, in suggesting he was unaware the decision had been made.
  2. The Mayor and his staff colluded to give him plausible deniability over declining the invitation.
  3. Council staff actually have authority to accept and decline civic invitations from international dignitaries.All three are troubling, but considering Cull has already been exposed for seeking advice from MFAT on the matter, after initially denying any external guidance was given, we may at least be able to rule out the third of these.

It would appear our Mayor has lost control of both his opinions and his diary. If Cull continues to roll over and play dead for any vested interests that come his way – the Otago Rugby Football Union / NZRU and Shell Oil to name two – he may find that come October he will have lost control of the city.

The local body elections this year could be interesting. It seems that the phoney war has already started.

May 16, 2013

In support of sculptor Stuart Griffiths

by Pete George

In response to Sculptor “not a local” Jeff King wrote:

I first met and shared a series of interesting flat adventures with outstanding sculptor Stuart Griffiths in 1978. At this time Stu was enthusiastic newly arrived into Christchurch from Hamilton. Than a notable Canterbury rugby star.

I can confirm without any reservation that Stu made an enlightened unique decision some decades ahead of the wisdom some enlightened others to move to Dunedin. Actually this occurred because he … meet and engaged in a lifetime commitment with another significant outstanding artist absolutely from Dunedin.

Technically Stu probably started his Dunedin commitment with a determination about 1979.    I was surprised by 1983 that Stu had made firm connections with my childhood neighbour monumental mason Ian Bingham.

All one can observe is how uninformed some who report to or take reports from  Dunedin City Council really are and how irrelevant some material published by this willing to say anything without verification fraternity is.

Without doubt Stu has been here in Dunos a very very very long time.

Other references for Stu: Ask another former flatmate Geoffrey (Rene) Logan [presentably of Nelson], who had the ability to name streets after family members in a relatively recent subdivision in Mosgiel.

The writers Credentials: Well My great great grandfather built the first house in Roslyn, then known in the 1860s as Irishtown. I sculpted The Water on Leith banks in 2010 through the Botanic Gardens, converting a section a 700 metre section of the drain into river with a beach: the beach was my idea.

It is a unique opportunity to work again within approximately the same location as Stu.

Exceptional renowned Architect Bill Hesson who organised and architected the Umbrella Tea Room (near Stu’s newly proposed circular arrangement) is known  to have expressed dismay that the umbrella concept was proposed and conceived by lead gardener of the Botanic Gardens, so it should be noted that this location is not without a history of previous dissent.

Whoever wrote s statement about Stu not being from Dunedin,  please acknowledge your ignorance and retract from the incorrectness of your statement.

Yours sincerely Jeff King, Civil Engineer

May 15, 2013

Sculptor “not a local”

by Pete George

Councillor Kate Wilson has apologised for criticising a sculptor for not being a local. The ODT reports:

A 150th anniversary monumental work proposed for the Dunedin Botanic Garden, Waterhead, had been criticised by councillors this week.

The botanic garden had sought permission to access funds from the Clive Lister Bequest in the 2013-14 financial year for a $60,000 work by Dunedin monumental sculptor Stuart Griffiths.

It was reported yesterday councillors had responded to the request on Monday with ”barely disguised outrage”.

Crs Kate Wilson and Jinty MacTavish also criticised Mr Griffiths’ selection, saying the sculptor was ”not a local”.

During annual plan deliberations yesterday, Cr Wilson publicly apologised for the comments.

It is understood councillors did an internet search on Mr Griffiths during the meeting, finding his former position as University of Canterbury lecturer in sculpture. Mr Griffiths has lived and worked in Dunedin since 1982.

1982 is 31 years ago, making the “not a local” snub a bit snobby.

I must admit that I am “not a local”. I first lived in Dunedin as a school boarder in 1972. I have been away from Dunedin a number of times since then but keep coming back.

I came back to work in Dunedin from 1973, and again in 1977. Then again in 1984. In 1984 I moved back to where I am theoretically a local, Lowburn, then came back to Dunedin in 2001.

One of my grandfathers worked in Port Chalmers and then after returning from serving in France in WW I as an engineer for Dunedin City Council, working on the Mahingerangi power scheme in the 1920s. My father was born in Belleknows and went to High School in Dunedin. My parents were married in Roslyn. My maternal grandparents and an uncle are buried in Andersons Bay. Two of my children were born in Dunedin and all three children had most of their education in Dunedin, from Kindergarten through to Polytechnic and University. I was married (the second time) in Dunedin.

But I probably don’t qualify as a local.

That doesn’t matter to me, I am committed to Dunedin and Otago as my home, and I am active in improving public interest and democratic involvement in Dunedin.

Non-locals are important in any city.

May 15, 2013

Demise of D Scene

by Pete George

Today’s issue of D Scene says that it’s demise is likely (on page 3). I’d already heard this was a possibility.

This is sad news, alternate and diverse media coverage helps the health of democracy and community.

Tags:
May 4, 2013

When snow is forecast…

by Pete George

…don’t worry, it rarely causes any problems apart from the cooler rain and wind we mostly get instead of snow at altitudes most of us live in Dunedin.

Tomorrow (Sunday) the forecast is snow to 400m, virtually no one in Dunedin lives at that altitude (see below). And with heavy rain forecast if we get a bit of snow amongst it it will melt quickly, especially as the ground hasn’t cooled much yet.

I live at 10o meters above sea level. Last year we got one light skiff of snow on the ground, didn’t cause us any disruption.

Every year or two we get one or two snowfalls that disrupt travel on the streets for a day or two. It’s usually far less of a problem for most of us than you might imagine by listening to what they say and show on TV.

May 3, 2013

Cull apologises about Dalia Lama comments

by Pete George

The ODT reports  Cull apologises; ‘regrets’ his Dalai Lama comments.

Mr Cull issued a statement yesterday apologising for his earlier comments, which he said had characterised the Dalai Lama as ”the leader of a minority sect”.

”While I understood I was speaking about the Dunedin context, that is no excuse for what was a dismissive and unnecessary slight.

”I sincerely regret my remarks and any offence to anyone including His Holiness and the Buddhist community both here and elsewhere,” Mr Cull’s statement read.

The fallout began after comments made by Mr Cull on Monday, while defending a decision not to introduce the Dalai Lama at next month’s public talk in Dunedin.

Is the Dalai Lama being given a special status?

Should the mayor accept every invitation to introduce religious leaders at public talks?

For example, what if Brian Tamaki asked Cull to introduce him at a Dunedin talk? Destiny Church is probably more significant in a New Zealand context than a sect of Buddhism.

May 3, 2013

Woodhouse gets the 3rd Degree

by Pete George

Michael Woodhouse was interviewed on 3rd Degree as Minister of Immigration.

3rd Degree interview: Michael Woodhouse: Video

The link to the associated story doesn’t work.

 

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.